Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil for Swimming in 2024

If you don’t want to read the entire article, you should know that my top pick is this L’Oreal Paris one (affiliate link). Great price, perfect quality, plenty of colors available – you won’t be disappointed.

If you want to look your best even after going for a swim or going through heavy rain, you must get one of my recommended waterproof eyebrow pencils.

This way, you will always look your best and never have to worry about your makeup dripping down your face.

Please note: We get commissions for purchases made through links in this article.

L’Oreal Paris Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil – Editor’s Choice
small image of L'Oreal waterproof eyebrow pencil
– Affordable and high quality
– 10 different color options
– Natural look
– Glides on easily, smudge and run-resistant
– Long-lasting wear
Check price
Bodermincer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil – Best Budget Option
small image of L'Oreal waterproof eyebrow pencil
– High quality at a low price
– 5 color options
– Natural filling and fake brow hairs creation
– Great value for money
Check price
Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
small image of Bodermincer waterproof eyebrow pencil
– Affordable with excellent brand/price ratio
– Blends easily with brow hair
– Waterproof, smear-proof formula
– 4 colors available
– Includes a mini-comb for grooming
Check price
Tat Brow Microblading Eyebrow Pencil
small image of Maybelline waterproof eyebrow pencil
– Ideal for minimal to no brow hairs
– Creates realistic, natural-looking brows
– Waterproof gel formula
– 4 colors available
– Easy to use
Check price
Covergirl Clean Fresh Brow Nano
small image of Covergirl waterproof eyebrow pencil
– Nano tip for natural strokes
– 6 shades available
– Vegan formula, free from parabens, mineral oil, talc, fragrance
– Dermatologically tested, suitable for sensitive skin
Check price

Now, let’s get a bit more in-depth with all the options and see what are the top choices. These products are perfect for when you go swimming, but they can be used on a daily basis without a problem.

Why swimming? Well, it’s the wettest environment you could get yourself into, and if the water there can’t change your eyebrows’ shape, nothing will! So based on my own experience, a waterproof eyebrow pencil offers the best quality even for daily use.

Without further ado, check out the best waterproof eyebrow pencil for swimming below.

L’Oreal Paris Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil – Editor’s Choice

loreal waterproof eyebrow pencil

This is an amazing eyebrow pencil that allows you to create a perfect look that lasts forever.

It’s affordable and high quality, coming with 10 different color options, from blonde to dark brunette – so you will surely find a matching one with easy.

It looks very natural and you will love it – and I dare say the same thing will be felt by anybody who sees you wearing it.

The formula glides on with ease, won’t smudge or run, and stays in place until you decide to remove it. Plus, you get a brand name that you know will never disappoint! One of the best waterproof eyebrow pencils I have tested and currently my favorite.

Click here to check it out.

Bodermincer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil – Best Budget Option

Best cheap waterproof eyebrow pencil

This is my best budget pick which, despite its really low price, works really well and offers really high quality for the money.

It offers five different colors to choose from and gives professional results. The texture is not too soft but not too hard either, so you can fill in brows naturally and create fake brow hairs in sparse areas.

Really good value for the money – just look at some photos posted by customers (following the link below) to see for yourself how well this cheap waterproof eyebrow pencil works!

Click here to check it out.

Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil

Another surprisingly cheap option, having in mind that it comes from such a well known brand and appreciated like Maybelline New York. Probably the best choice on the list if you’re looking for brand/price ratio (yes, I just created that!).

This eyebrow pencil blends easily with brow hair and it has a waterproof, smear proof formula that you can wear all day.

Four colors to choose from and the included mini-comb works well to groom your brows for that perfect look.

Click here to check the price.

Tat Brow Microblading Eyebrow Pencil

waterproof tatbrow microblade pen

This is a perfect waterproof eyebrow pencils for those who don’t have any (or just minimal hairs) in your brow.

It is very suitable for creating realistic brows as well, that look natural and nice. Press lightly for lighter shades and as you build it up and press harder so it gets darker.

Easy to use and wear, coming in 4 different colors – choose the one that’s most suitable and enjoy! Just have in mind that this is not a traditional pen, but one using a waterproof gel instead. Shouldn’t matter too much as long as it gets the job done well!

Click here to check it out.

Covergirl Clean Fresh Brow Nano

covergirl clean fresh

A newer entry on the market, but also a product that I tested and really liked. The main attraction is the nano tip which allows for some amazingly natural strokes.

It comes in six shades and follows all the health rules you should care about: vegan formula, formulated without parabens, mineral oil, talc, fragrance.

It is dermatologically tested and recommended for sensitive skin also, for a great modern take on the classic eyebrow pencil.

Click here to check it out.


All of the products above are some perfect picks – just choose the one that you like the most or go with my top recommendation, the L’Oreal Paris one.

When it comes to your eyebrows, there’s not much you can change about them daily, as you can do with eye makeup or lipstick.

The good news about eyebrow makeup is that you can’t change it unless you’re changing the color of your hair, drastically I might add, that once you have an eyebrow pencil you love, you are set for life (its life, not yours).

And this is the reason why you need to get a great product, one that works perfectly with you and makes your eyebrows look perfect also.

Even for everyday use, your best bet is getting a waterproof eyebrow pencil – no matter if you plan to go swimming or you just get through an unexpected rain, it will still be there for you!

The truth is that no matter which one you pick from the list above, you will be extremely satisfied with the results.

In my case, I have some small scars in my eyebrows, where no hair is growing, but with any of these products, I can cover them easily and get those perfect looks that are also durable.

I don’t have to worry anymore that, after swimming or staying in the rain (or just sweating) my scars will be back and my perfect brows ruined.

Just make sure, before buying your eyebrow pencil, that you’re not planning to change your hair color soon. Also, having a steady hand applying it is a must as these pencils recommended above are pretty difficult to remove once you apply them (which is still an advantage since they’re long-lasting!)

Leave a Comment